
I'm thrilled to have finished another reading challenge book! I just wish the book had been better.
I know this series is madly popular, especially here in MN. Even the older books have waiting lists on book swap sites. So, I went into it thinking I would just love its cozy setting and characters. I've always been a big fan of books and movies set in a diner, general store or similar where all types of characters come and go. It's a great way to make introductions to the audience as to who these folks are and a great way to keep up with them. All the elements seemed to be there for a great read. However, it was missing a likable protagonist.
The plot of this book was OK, although it seemed to bulge at the seams a bit. The secondary characters were pleasant enough, if not a bit bland. My biggest issue with this story (and maybe the series?) is Hannah's involvement with the investigation of a murder. She seemed to thumb her nose at authorities and went too far by breaking and entering and other assorted things. I much prefer an amateur sleuth stumbling onto things or if s/he does do some investigating, it isn't so reckless. She came off quite arrogant. The explanation by the author as to why Hannah and friends did certain things didn't hold water for me.
I'm not sure where to go from here since I wasn't that impressed. I have many more books from this series loaded into my iTunes to eventually listen to on my iPod. I believe this is the second book. It can make some people shake if they even think about reading a series out of order. I do prefer that for character development purposes but it isn't something I have to do. I feel if it's a good book, it should be able to stand on its own.
I do see potential in some characters and will most likely give a later book a try to see if things have improved with Hannah and how she handles herself with the investigating. If she hasn't, then I guess this series isn't for me.
Rating: C+